Respondent name
Satnam Millennium
Responses
Respondent Type
Landowner/developer
Policy Name/Part of plan
MD4
Legally Compliant
No
Sound
No
Oral Examination
Yes
Modification if applicable

Remove allocation from Local Plan or amend policy requirements to align with planning permission granted on Appeal.

Summary of comments

Planning Permission for this site was granted at appeal on 9/11/21 for its development in form similar to the proposed allocation. As such the plan should be amended to notate the site as a commitment rather than an allocation and the Policy thus deleted. If, for whatever reason the proposed allocation remains relevant, then amendments are required to make the Plan sound.

Respondent Type
Landowner/developer
Policy Name/Part of plan
MD4
Legally Compliant
No
Sound
No
Oral Examination
Yes
Modification if applicable

Include site in first 5 years of housing trajectory.

Summary of comments

The policy is overly long and verbose, many of the matters raised are detailed points for the application and determination stage. The policy is negatively phrased and is not positively prepared. As a result of this negativity, the housing trajectory of the plan does not anticipate housing delivery on this site within the first 5 years of the plan. Peel Hall is the most investigated and worked up of the development areas allocated in the plan (as a result of the 2 recent planning appeals on the site) and the development of homes on the site should be included in the first 5 years of the trajectory.

Respondent Type
Landowner/developer
Policy Name/Part of plan
MD4
Legally Compliant
No
Sound
No
Oral Examination
Yes
Modification if applicable

Amend policy to read a MINIMUM of 1,200 new homes.

Summary of comments

?of up to 1,200 new homes?? This wording is negative and not positive planning. It places an artificial ceiling on the capacity of the site.

Paragraph/policy sub

Part 1

Respondent Type
Landowner/developer
Policy Name/Part of plan
MD4
Legally Compliant
No
Sound
No
Oral Examination
Yes
Modification if applicable

Delete the words ?as agreed by the Council and Highways England? and replace it with ?as are proportionate and necessary to prevent an unacceptable impact on highway safety, and / or severe residual cumulative impacts on the road network.?

Summary of comments

Requires highway improvements ?as agreed by the Council and Highways England?. It is not appropriate for a policy to require a particular party to give their agreement.

Paragraph/policy sub

Part 1 e

Respondent Type
Landowner/developer
Policy Name/Part of plan
MD4
Legally Compliant
No
Sound
No
Oral Examination
Yes
Modification if applicable

Delete the words ?as agreed by the Council and Highways England? and replace it with ?as are proportionate and necessary to prevent an unacceptable impact on highway safety, and / or severe residual cumulative impacts on the road network.?

Summary of comments

Requires highway improvements ?as agreed by the Council and Highways England?. It is not appropriate for a policy to require a particular party to give their agreement.

Paragraph/policy sub

Part 5

Respondent Type
Landowner/developer
Policy Name/Part of plan
MD4
Legally Compliant
No
Sound
No
Oral Examination
Yes
Modification if applicable

Removed reference to be agreed by the Council.

Summary of comments

Queries the programme and funding for the delivery of the primary school and other community infrastructure to be ?agreed by the Council? before the first phase of the development is permitted to come forward.

Paragraph/policy sub

Part 7

Respondent Type
Landowner/developer
Policy Name/Part of plan
MD4
Legally Compliant
No
Sound
No
Oral Examination
Yes
Modification if applicable

Amend policy and remove the words as identified in policy DEV2.

Summary of comments

Policy states ?A range of housing tenures, types and sizes, as identified in Policy DEV2, should be provided ???.?. DEV2 does not identify a range of housing types and sizes, it states that residential development should provide a mix of different housing sizes and types and should be informed by the Borough-wide housing mix monitoring target.

Paragraph/policy sub

Part 8

Respondent Type
Landowner/developer
Policy Name/Part of plan
MD4
Legally Compliant
No
Sound
No
Oral Examination
Yes
Modification if applicable

Amend policy to remove the words no access and egress from Poplars Avenue, except for public transport, active travel, emergency services and a minimal number of dwellings fronting the access links.

Summary of comments

requires ?no access and egress from Poplars Avenue, except for public transport, active travel, emergency services and a minimal number of dwellings fronting the access links? The recent public inquiry into an appeal on this site (March 21) confirmed the acceptability of some access onto this road (albeit not an exact, agreed quantum).

Paragraph/policy sub

Part 21 a

Respondent Type
Landowner/developer
Policy Name/Part of plan
MD4
Legally Compliant
No
Sound
No
Oral Examination
Yes
Modification if applicable

Amend policy and remove wording.

Summary of comments

Policy 4.3 repeats the requirement for the Council and Highways England?s ?agreement? for the highways mitigation package.

Paragraph/policy sub

Part 21b

Respondent Type
Landowner/developer
Policy Name/Part of plan
MD4
Legally Compliant
No
Sound
No
Oral Examination
Yes
Modification if applicable

Amend policy and remove wording.

Summary of comments

unclear and imprecise. It requires other necessary network improvements on the Local and Strategic Road Network as identified by an appropriate Transport Assessment. The policy assumes that such improvements are necessary before an assessment has been conducted.

Paragraph/policy sub

Part 21e

Respondent Type
Landowner/developer
Policy Name/Part of plan
MD4
Legally Compliant
No
Sound
No
Oral Examination
Yes
Modification if applicable

Amend policy and remove wording.

Summary of comments

vague and unspecified; it refers to the development changing ?the character of these established residential areas?. There is no reference within the plan as to the character assessment appropriate for the consideration of harmful change to these areas.

Paragraph/policy sub

Part 24

Respondent Type
Landowner/developer
Policy Name/Part of plan
MD4
Legally Compliant
No
Sound
No
Oral Examination
Yes
Modification if applicable

To avoid confusion the words ?as well as providing a wider resource for north Warrington? should be deleted. If it is considered appropriate to note that park to serve the needs of the development will also be a wider resource for north Warrington that note could be included in the reasoned justification.

Summary of comments

The policy provides that there should be a major new park ?to provide a proportion of the open space and recreational needs of the development as well as providing a wider resource for north Warrington.? It is not clear from the wording whether land is intended to be allocated for a park to serve the needs of north Warrington, or whether the wording seeks to note that the park which provides for the needs of the development will also be a wider resource for north Warrington.

Paragraph/policy sub

Part 28

Respondent Type
Landowner/developer
Policy Name/Part of plan
MD4
Legally Compliant
No
Sound
No
Oral Examination
Yes
Modification if applicable

Amend policy and remove wording.

Summary of comments

Part 31 is unclear. The extent of the contributions required is not clear. Any contribution should be limited to that which meets the tests set out in regulation 122(2) of the Community Infrastructure Levy Regulations 2010.

Paragraph/policy sub

Part 31

Respondent Type
Landowner/developer
Policy Name/Part of plan
MD4
Legally Compliant
No
Sound
No
Oral Examination
Yes
Modification if applicable

Amend policy and remove wording.

Summary of comments

refers to the delivery of ?a new road connecting the development to the Local Road Network? No information on this road is set out in the plan, nor is the route of the road shown. This requirement is unjustified and is unsound; there is no evidence to demonstrate that there is a requirement for a new road to connect the development to the Local Road Network.

Paragraph/policy sub

Par 10.4.10